PolySand Fenceposts
Designing cost effective building materials using local waste with the charity WasteAid.
Final year SOLO project, 2019
Polysand is a novel material made from waste plastic and sand.
The production of cost effective polysand fenceposts facilitates environmental clear up and creates locally useful products.
Context
Beach pollution in Gunjur, The Gambia
Credits: WasteAid UK
I focused my work in Gunjur, a village in The Gambia where WasteAid are working on a plastic recycling project. Here pollution has become a serious local issue
Although the lack of waste management is a global problem.
My challenge was to find product applications for this material that are driven by local needs, are cost effective and take into account the properties of the material.
Typical fence construction with posts connected with wire
Fences and walls are ubiquitous throughout the world but hold a particular relevance for Sub-Saharan
African countries where compound housing is incredibly popular especially in rural and low-income areas.
A case for Polysand
Polysand is novel material made from low density polyethylene (LDPE) and sand.
LDPE films are one of the most common and problematic waste streams.
It is used widely for packaging and often cannot be recycled.
Typically, because of the cost of collecting and processing waste upcycled or recycled
goods are artisanal and unscalable.
The addition of sand dramatically
improves the material properties while dramatically lowering the cost of manufacturing
compared to making pure plastic products.
Polysand is made from 75% sand which acts as aggregate bound together by the plastic.
The material properties have been characterised by the researchers at Imperial
College London (paper here)
who liken the material to concrete.
Polysand is currently being used to make paving tiles in a WasteAid workshop in Gunjur in the Gambia.
Polysand tiles being laid in Gunjur, The Gambia.
Credits: WasteAid UK
Optimisation
Fenceposts are fairly low value, so to make a sustainable business case, the product had to be optimised for cost effectiveness and designed for low cost manufacturing techniques.
Graph showing the mass and maximum stress of different beam cross sections
Different cross sectional geometries with the same baseline dimensions were compared in three categories:
strength, mass and ease of manufacture. Strength was tested using FEA simulations of the fencepost under loading and the
maximum stress was recorded. Ease of manufacture was approximated depending on the complexity
of mould required to produce the shape. An overall score was calculated from these three
metrics and the best cross section selected.
Graph showing the ease of manufacture and different beam cross sections
Although subjective, this method helped me
select an appropriate design to then optimise numerically.
The following is the beam bending formulation
that was used to numerically minimise the volume of the beam while satisfying that the bending stress is less than the strength of the material.
Optimisation formulation for cross-section dimensions
Diagram of dimension variables
The MATLAB optimisation solution gave the dimensions for the fencepost design.
Prototype
I built a segment of fencepost with the correct cross sectional area
as a proof of concept of the material capabilities and manufacturing
techniques.
Working with a novel material meant that I had to learn the best way
to manipulate it. I was also trying to emulate the low cost tools that would
be available in the field.
Wooden mould used to make final prototype.
After much experimentation, I built a robust three part mould that could
be seperated easily to remove the end piece.
The material was heated in an oven and pressed into the mould.
Final prototype - fencepost segment.
Life Cycle Analysis (LCA)
The optimised solution was compared to current solutions using an open
source LCA tool. A holistic analysis of materials, manufacturing, transport
and end of life was considered.
Compared to concrete and pine wood solutions, Polysand had the lowest aggregrate
score for Energy Consumption, Carbon Dioxide, and other Emvironmental Impact Factors.
Cost Analysis
An approximation of costs, using local values for wages and materials showed that
the optimised deisgn was competitive with conventional materials.
Conclusion
Polysand as a material has a lot of potential as an alternative
for fenceposts. However, the design needs to be tested in the field.
I look forward to seeing the project evolve in The Gambia with WasteAid
and beyond.